Thanks for the timely survey, as I am planning on (finally) getting around to my swap this winter. I originally thought I'd go with the AMD stg3+ although it sounds like there's a decent amount of chatter, of which I'm not a fan. My priorities are: good pedal feel with consistent and positive engagement point. Suggestions?

For some reference, I used to have an mkv GTI (which was fun) but I absolutely could not stand its clutch. The pedal was feather light and the engagement point seemed to float around. I want to make sure I avoid that type of clutch.