PDA

View Full Version : Bent wheels - straighten or replace?



Turbowned
February 7th, 2014, 14:54
Gentlemen,

This past Monday I blasted a pothole with my RF wheel and ruined a perfectly good Michelin Pilot Alpin 3. The good news is that the spare tire worked great despite never being used before, and that despite being discontinued, Tire Rack had three PA3's left and shipped one to my work the next day, in the middle of a snowstorm no less!

The bad news is my wheel is now out-of-round somewhat, because I now get a vibration at 50-55mph. When I had the winter tires mounted two months ago, my technician friend noted that two of the wheels were slightly bent, and I could see this when he put them on the tire balancer. We put those wheels on the rear of the car. Before hitting the pothole there was a very slight vibration at speed; more of a minor nuisance than anything.

What I'm wondering is if it would be worthwhile to spend the $3-400 to have them straightened and the curb rash repaired, or to look for a different set of wheels. There is an alloy wheel repair specialist less than a mile from my work. The wheels aren't visibly bent, meaning there's no nasty bends when you look at them straight on; you only notice it when you put them on a balancer and spin them. If this were a cheap econobox I probably wouldn't even bother fixing or replacing them, but this is a high-performance car designed to travel at high speed, and while I don't really want to shell out for new wheels, I also don't want to half-ass anything. Thoughts?

Corbett
February 7th, 2014, 15:16
If there are no nasty bends or cracks then have them repaired. Much cheaper and will look like new

Jimmy
February 7th, 2014, 15:56
I don't know man. If your guy is going to charge 3-400 to fix one rim, then it's high time to find another guy, sorry, just IMO.

Curbed and bent rims are fixed here and re-finished in CT for $125-175 a rim. Yours doesn't even sound like a bad bend. 'The Wheel Shop' in Windsor Locks by Bradley Airport. Rob is the man to speak to.

Turbowned
February 7th, 2014, 17:37
$3-400 to fix all four. $75-100 each wheel.

kvicen
February 7th, 2014, 17:57
I would fix all four. They will be straight, repainted, and look new. Best of all it's usually a 24 hour turnaround.

ttboost
February 8th, 2014, 12:17
Yep..fix 'em. I've already fixed 2 of my BBS CH-R's on my Benz, and they were bent AND cracked. They are now for sale, because they will just bend and crack again with these New England roads...

Jimmy
February 10th, 2014, 13:16
$3-400 to fix all four. $75-100 each wheel.
Gotcha...that is a great price then !

nistah
February 10th, 2014, 14:41
Turbowned Can pls you post a pic of the RF's? Would love to see what they look like

ben916
February 10th, 2014, 19:09
A temp fix would to use the fold-a-flat spare tire rim and mount the MPA on it until spring.
There is a Audi specific website that has spares of the OEM rims ($200-$250 IIRC).

I found that website while surfing/searching for OEM RS4 rims in 19"; the website was listed on Audizine. (yeah, not much help but better than zip)

Turbowned
February 10th, 2014, 20:25
Turbowned Can pls you post a pic of the RF's? Would love to see what they look like

Oh no, "RF" stood for "right front", I do not have BBS RF's on my car (which is what I assume you're referring to?)

Turns out it was a bad outer tie rod end with a lot of play in it. Ordered a Lemforder replacement that should be here this week. Still going to re-finish the wheels eventually.

dab
February 10th, 2014, 22:20
I use a company called alloy wheel repair, the come to you in your driveway and fix it if it is fixable. 125 per rim, I have had them work on my hartmanns rs4 forged piece of shit multiple times. Looked into investing in a territory.

JSRS6
February 10th, 2014, 23:11
Just found out I have a bad inner on the driver side. Gonna order and replace ASAP. That shits annoying.
Oh no, "RF" stood for "right front", I do not have BBS RF's on my car (which is what I assume you're referring to?)

Turns out it was a bad outer tie rod end with a lot of play in it. Ordered a Lemforder replacement that should be here this week. Still going to re-finish the wheels eventually.

Turbowned
February 11th, 2014, 23:08
I use a company called alloy wheel repair, the come to you in your driveway and fix it if it is fixable. 125 per rim, I have had them work on my hartmanns rs4 forged piece of shit multiple times. Looked into investing in a territory.

Same company out here. Right down the street from my work and I work at a dealership that uses them so I get it done a little cheaper, thankfully.

4everRS
February 12th, 2014, 01:50
Josh, what sound are you noticing? I used Meyle HD's for tie rod ends and was very happy with them.


Just found out I have a bad inner on the driver side. Gonna order and replace ASAP. That shits annoying.

JSRS6
February 12th, 2014, 03:00
Not really any noise to speak of, Kyle. It is the subtle vibration and poor tracking of the car that is a bother. My shop checked all the control arms and tie rods and concluded the driver inner has play. So the culprit has been ousted! Haha!
Josh, what sound are you noticing? I used Meyle HD's for tie rod ends and was very happy with them.

Turbowned
February 12th, 2014, 03:06
Josh I want all your mods. Jussayin'

JSRS6
February 12th, 2014, 04:08
Bbbbbbbut they're mine......

hahahaha. But seriously. Thanks for compliment. Don't forget though, your car is a direct reflection of you. So make it uniquely your own. You'll be happy you did. But definitely spring for the 9500ci. It's saved my ass plenty of times.


Josh I want all your mods. Jussayin'