Your top 3 'carreviewjournalist'

[Michaël Barbé]

(s) Mine:

1) Jeremy Clarkson (Top Gear)

2) Chris Harris (Autocar)

3) Jason Plato (5th gear)

Sometimes number 2 and 3 switch place. Number one is as good as irreplaceable.

Michaël Barbé
:rs6kiss:

[Bingocaller]

1) Jeremy Clarkson (Top Gear)

2) James May (Top Gear)

3) Chris Harris (Autocar)

[Michaël Barbé]

wow you guys are excited about this thread!

MB
:rs6kiss:

[artur777]

Agree about all except Jeremy Clarkson. Nothing personal, but I don't like his style and reviews.

[Leadfoot]

(s) Mine:

1) Jeremy Clarkson (Top Gear)

2) Chris Harris (Autocar)

3) Jason Plato (5th gear)

Sometimes number 2 and 3 switch place. Number one is as good as irreplaceable.

Michaël Barbé
:rs6kiss:

Chris is usually the most unbiased of the three and you get a common man's opinion of how the car being reviewed really is, not always what you want to hear though.

Richard Hammon is similar to Chris in that you know he's down to earth in his opinions.

Jeremy Clarkson is not the best reviewer there is but what he lacks in skill or unbiased views he makes up for in wit and humour. I recommend everyone get to a TopGear show as the experience is well worth it.

But the one person I rate better than all the above is one 'Captain Slow', James May for me is the funnest one of the lot and you can see that he neither has an ego or a total love of cars which the others clearly do. He's totally unbiased.

[Michaël Barbé]

so: Leadfoots top 3:

1) James May
2) ...
3) ...

[cornishmoocher]

1) James May
2) Tiff ( his voice drives me nuts- but he knows his onions)
3)Vicki butler henderson- because she has great ........

[Leadfoot]

On humour
James May
Jeremy Clarkson
Richard Hammon

On ability and knowledge
Tiff
Plato
Vikki

On believe-ability
Chris Harris
James May

[Michaël Barbé]

It's really more the top 3 you would choose if you had to pick 3 'reviewers'. On what bases doesn't make any difference...

MB
:rs6kiss: